I didn’t enjoy J Blakeson’s recent black comedy I Care a Lot. For those who haven’t yet seen it, it’s the story of Marla (Rosamund Pike), a calculating psychopath who takes over the legal guardianship of elderly people, has them placed in assisted-living facilities, and scams them out of their money and possessions. When she crosses the wrong old lady, she ends up in the crosshairs of Peter Dinklage’s violent Russian mobster, and must fight for her survival.
I Care a Lot seems tailor-made for my tastes. It’s A) a black comedy B) about a despicable monster scheming their way out of trouble C) with lots of violence and style. So why did I dislike it so much? It’s certainly not because of Rosamund Pike’s performance. She’s as reliable as ever, relishing another opportunity to break bad and be as cruel as possible. Unlike other critics, I don’t even think the issue is that Marla is irredeemable, as I have seen and loved many films about morally bankrupt characters going about their lives.
No, I Care a Lot has a few fatal flaws that really killed any enjoyment I had of it. While I could spend more time talking about the dumb plotting that sees characters acting incompetently when the script needs it, or the weak satire that fires wildly at multiple targets (missing most of them), I want to look in-depth at Marla, and irredeemable characters in general. Specifically, I believe there are three main ways of writing unlikeable characters, none of which I Care a Lot manages to do. Let’s break them down:
Continue reading